The Metropolis Algorithm for the Planted Clique Problem

More than 30 year ago Jerrum studied the planted clique problem and proved that under worst-case initialization Metropolis fails to recover planted cliques of size $\ll n^{1/2}$ in the Erdős-Rényi graph $G(n,1/2)$. This result is classically cited in the literature of the problem, as the "first evidence" that finding planted cliques of size much smaller than square root $n$ is "algorithmically hard". Cliques of size $\gg n^{1/2}$ are easy to find using simple algorithms. In a recent work we show that the Metropolis process actually fails to find planted cliques under worst-case initialization for cliques up to size almost linear in $n$. Thus the algorithm fails well beyond the $\sqrt{n}$ "conjectured algorithmic threshold". We also prove that, for a large parameter regime, that the Metropolis process fails also under "natural initialization". Our results resolve some open questions posed by Jerrum in 1992. Based on joint work with Zongchen Chen and Iias Zadik.