Symmetry Operators and Gravity

It was recently argued that topological operators (at least those associated with continuous symmetries) need regularization. However, such regularization seems to be ill-defined when the underlying QFT is coupled to gravity. If both of these claims are correct, it means that charges cannot be meaningfully measured in the presence of gravity. I will review the evidence supporting these claims as discussed in [arXiv:2411.08858]. Given the audience's high level of expertise, I hope this will spark discussion about whether this is a promising approach to understanding the fate of global symmetries in quantum gravity.