Mathematical modelling and stochastic optimization are often based on the separation of two stages: At the first stage, a model is selected out of a family of plausible models and at the second stage, a policy is chosen that optimizes an underlying objective as if the chosen model were correct. In this talk, I will introduce a new approach which, rather than completely isolating the two stages, interlinks them dynamically. I will first introduce the notion of “consequential performance” of each model and, in turn, propose a “consequentialist criterion for model selection” based on the expected utility of consequential performances. I will apply the approach to continuous-time portfolio selection and derive a key system of coupled PDEs and solve it for representative cases. I will, also, discuss the connection of the new approach with the popular methods of robust control and of unbiased estimators. This is joint work with M. Strub (U. of Warwick)
