Since the early 20th century, it was speculated that signed networks tend to display "structural balance". This is where certain configurations of positive and negative edges capture the property that a "friend of a friend is a friend" and the "friend of an enemy is an enemy". Originating in mathematical psychology for the purpose of studying triadic interactions, the notion of balance has since been generalised, and is believed to manifest outside of social systems.
Efforts have been made to quantify structural balance, which is rarely fully displayed in real world networks. In this talk, we will discuss current measures of balance and their fallacies, which tend to arise from computing what balance is not – as opposed to what it is. In turn, we propose a probabilistic model for structural balance, and suggest an inferential framework to robustly assess it's manifestation in real data.