Seminar series
Date
Thu, 26 Nov 2026
11:00
Location
C6
Speaker
Robin Knight
Organisation
Oxford University
Add to calendar

Joint work with Nate Ackerman, Harvard and Cameron Freer, MIT.

The negation of Vaught's Conjecture for the infinitary logic ${\mathcal L}_{\omega_1,\omega}$ is the statement that, if the continuum hypothesis is false, there is a sentence $T$ of this logic which has exactly $\aleph_1$ countable models. This is equivalent to the existence of a continuous action of the permutation group $S_\infty$ of the integers on a Polish space (such as the irrationals) with exactly $\aleph_1$ orbits. Both statements can be phrased in such a way as to avoid mention of the continuum hypothesis.

In October, the authors announced such a counterexample that had been expressed and verified in the theorem-proving language Lean. This uses ideas deriving from the proposed counterexample to Vaught's Conjecture in first-order logic circulated by the speaker in 2002.

Last updated on 20 Nov 2026, 4:12pm. Please contact us with feedback and comments about this page.