Mathematising certainty in the 18th century. Jacob Bernoulli’s and Thomas Bayes’ redefinition of “absolute” and “moral” certainty through probability calculus
Abstract
In the 17th century, certainty was still largely organized around heterogeneous categories such as “absolute certainty” and “moral certainty”. “Absolute certainty” was the highest kind of certainty rather than degree and it was limited to metaphysical and mathematical demonstrations. On the other hand, “moral certainty” was a high degree of assent which, even though it was subjective and always fallible, was regarded as sufficient for practical decisions based on empirical evidence. Although this duality between “moral” and “absolute” certainty remained in use well into the 18th century, its meaning shifted with the emergence of the calculus of probabilities. Probability calculus provided tools for attempts to mathematise “moral certainty” which would have been a contradiction in terms in their classical 17th-century sense.
Jacob Bernoulli's Ars Conjectandi (1713) followed by Thomas Bayes and Richard Price's An Essay towards solving a Problem in the Doctrine of Chances (1763) reshuffled what was before mutually exclusive characteristics of those categories of certainty. Moral certainty became mathematizable and measurable, while absolute certainty would sit in continuity in degree with moral certainty rather than be different in kind. The concept of certainty as a whole is thus redefined as a quantitative continuum.
This transformation lays the conceptual foundations for a new approach to knowledge. Knowledge and even scientific knowledge are no longer defined by a binary model of an absolute exclusion of uncertainty, but rather by the accuracy of measurement of the irreducible uncertainty in all empirical-based knowledge. Such measurement becomes possible thanks to the new tools provided by the emergence of probability calculus.
16:30
The Alan Tayler Lecture 2023 - The Maths (and Engineering) of Moving People and Things Around
St Catherine’s College has a long tradition in applied and industrial mathematics and has hosted an annual series of lectures on Mathematics and its Applications since 1986. In 1995, the series was renamed in memory of Alan Tayler, in tribute to his efforts and achievements in this field. Alan was the first Fellow in Applied Mathematics to be appointed at St Catherine’s. His lifelong commitment was to the practical application of mathematical ideas to problems in science and industry. His vision continues to inspire many national and international collaborations on the theme of mathematics-in-industry.
Registration: this event has limited capacity so it is recommended to register to confirm a space. To sign up to this event please complete the form.
The Zilber-Pink conjecture: a review
Abstract
I will recall the Zilber-Pink conjecture for Shimura varieties and give my perspective on current progress towards a proof.
New ideas in Arakelov intersection theory
Abstract
I will give an overview of new ideas showing up in arithmetic intersection theory based on some exciting talks that appeared at the very recent conference "Global invariants of arithmetic varieties". I will also outline connections to globally valued fields and some classical problems.
15:00
On the abelianization of the level 2 congruence group of the mapping class group.
Abstract
We will survey work of Birman-Craggs, Johnson, and Sato on the abelianization of the level 2 congruence group of the mapping class group of a surface, and of the corresponding Torelli group. We will then describe recent work of Lewis providing a common framework for both abelianizations, with applications including a partial answer to a question of Johnson.