Forthcoming events in this series


Thu, 31 Oct 2019

14:00 - 15:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

On coarse spaces for solving the heterogenous Helmholtz equation with domain decomposition methods

Niall Bootland
(University of Strathclyde)
Abstract

The development of effective solvers for high frequency wave propagation problems, such as those described by the Helmholtz equation, presents significant challenges. One promising class of solvers for such problems are parallel domain decomposition methods, however, an appropriate coarse space is typically required in order to obtain robust behaviour (scalable with respect to the number of domains, weakly dependant on the wave number but also on the heterogeneity of the physical parameters). In this talk we introduce a coarse space based on generalised eigenproblems in the overlap (GenEO) for the Helmholtz equation. Numerical results within FreeFEM demonstrate convergence that is effectively independent of the wave number and contrast in the heterogeneous coefficient as well as good performance for minimal overlap.

Thu, 24 Oct 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Reliable Real Computing

Fredrik Johansson
(University of Bordeaux)
Abstract

Can we get rigorous answers when computing with real and complex numbers? There are now many applications where this is possible thanks to a combination of tools from computer algebra and traditional numerical computing. I will give an overview of such methods in the context of two projects I'm developing. The first project, Arb, is a library for arbitrary-precision ball arithmetic, a form of interval arithmetic enabling numerical computations with rigorous error bounds. The second project, Fungrim, is a database of knowledge about mathematical functions represented in symbolic form. It is intended to function both as a traditional reference work and as a software library to support symbolic-numeric methods for problems involving transcendental functions. I will explain a few central algorithmic ideas and explain the research goals of these projects.

Thu, 20 Jun 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Overcoming the curse of dimensionality: from nonlinear Monte Carlo to deep artificial neural networks

Professor Arnulf Jentzen
(ETH Zurich)
Abstract

Partial differential equations (PDEs) are among the most universal tools used in modelling problems in nature and man-made complex systems. For example, stochastic PDEs are a fundamental ingredient in models for nonlinear filtering problems in chemical engineering and weather forecasting, deterministic Schroedinger PDEs describe the wave function in a quantum physical system, deterministic Hamiltonian-Jacobi-Bellman PDEs are employed in operations research to describe optimal control problems where companys aim to minimise their costs, and deterministic Black-Scholes-type PDEs are highly employed in portfolio optimization models as well as in state-of-the-art pricing and hedging models for financial derivatives. The PDEs appearing in such models are often high-dimensional as the number of dimensions, roughly speaking, corresponds to the number of all involved interacting substances, particles, resources, agents, or assets in the model. For instance, in the case of the above mentioned financial engineering models the dimensionality of the PDE often corresponds to the number of financial assets in the involved hedging portfolio. Such PDEs can typically not be solved explicitly and it is one of the most challenging tasks in applied mathematics to develop approximation algorithms which are able to approximatively compute solutions of high-dimensional PDEs. Nearly all approximation algorithms for PDEs in the literature suffer from the so-called "curse of dimensionality" in the sense that the number of required computational operations of the approximation algorithm to achieve a given approximation accuracy grows exponentially in the dimension of the considered PDE. With such algorithms it is impossible to approximatively compute solutions of high-dimensional PDEs even when the fastest currently available computers are used. In the case of linear parabolic PDEs and approximations at a fixed space-time point, the curse of dimensionality can be overcome by means of Monte Carlo approximation algorithms and the Feynman-Kac formula. In this talk we introduce new nonlinear Monte Carlo algorithms for high-dimensional nonlinear PDEs. We prove that such algorithms do indeed overcome the curse of dimensionality in the case of a general class of semilinear parabolic PDEs and we thereby prove, for the first time, that a general semilinear parabolic PDE with a nonlinearity depending on the PDE solution can be solved approximatively without the curse of dimensionality.

Thu, 13 Jun 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

A structure-preserving finite element method for uniaxial nematic liquid crystals

Professor Ricardo Nochetto
(University of Maryland)
Abstract

The Landau-DeGennes Q-model of uniaxial nematic liquid crystals seeks a rank-one

traceless tensor Q that minimizes a Frank-type energy plus a double well potential

that confines the eigenvalues of Q to lie between -1/2 and 1. We propose a finite

element method (FEM) which preserves this basic structure and satisfies a discrete

form of the fundamental energy estimates. We prove that the discrete problem Gamma

converges to the continuous one as the meshsize tends to zero, and propose a discrete

gradient flow to compute discrete minimizers. Numerical experiments confirm the ability

of the scheme to approximate configurations with half-integer defects, and to deal with

colloidal and electric field effects. This work, joint with J.P. Borthagaray and S.

Walker, builds on our previous work for the Ericksen's model which we review briefly.

Thu, 06 Jun 2019

14:00 - 15:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

Parallel numerical algorithms for resilient large scale simulations

Dr Mawussi Zounon
(Numerical Algorithms Group & University of Manchester)
Abstract

As parallel computers approach Exascale (10^18 floating point operations per second), processor failure and data corruption are of increasing concern. Numerical linear algebra solvers are at the heart of many scientific and engineering applications, and with the increasing failure rates, they may fail to compute a solution or produce an incorrect solution. It is therefore crucial to develop novel parallel linear algebra solvers capable of providing correct solutions on unreliable computing systems. The common way to mitigate failures in high performance computing systems consists of periodically saving data onto a reliable storage device such as a remote disk. But considering the increasing failure rate and the ever-growing volume of data involved in numerical simulations, the state-of-the-art fault-tolerant strategies are becoming time consuming, therefore unsuitable for large-scale simulations. In this talk, we will present a  novel class of fault-tolerant algorithms that do not require any additional resources. The key idea is to leverage the knowledge of numerical properties of solvers involved in a simulation to regenerate lost data due to system failures. We will also share the lessons learned and report on the numerical properties and the performance of the new resilience algorithms.

Thu, 30 May 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Near-best adaptive approximation

Professor Peter Binev
(University of South Carolina)
Abstract

One of the major steps in the adaptive finite element methods (AFEM) is the adaptive selection of the next partition. The process is usually governed by a strategy based on carefully chosen local error indicators and aims at convergence results with optimal rates. One can formally relate the refinement of the partitions with growing an oriented graph or a tree. Then each node of the tree/graph corresponds to a cell of a partition and the approximation of a function on adaptive partitions can be expressed trough the local errors related to the cell, i.e., the node. The total approximation error is then calculated as the sum of the errors on the leaves (the terminal nodes) of the tree/graph and the problem of finding an optimal error for a given budget of nodes is known as tree approximation. Establishing a near-best tree approximation result is a key ingredient in proving optimal convergence rates for AFEM.

 

The classical tree approximation problems are usually related to the so-called h-adaptive approximation in which the improvements a due to reducing the size of the cells in the partition. This talk will consider also an extension of this framework to hp-adaptive approximation allowing different polynomial spaces to be used for the local approximations at different cells while maintaining the near-optimality in terms of the combined number of degrees of freedom used in the approximation.

 

The problem of conformity of the resulting partition will be discussed as well. Typically in AFEM, certain elements of the current partition are marked and subdivided together with some additional ones to maintain desired properties of the partition like conformity. This strategy is often described as “mark → subdivide → complete”. The process is very well understood for triangulations received via newest vertex bisection procedure. In particular, it is proven that the number of elements in the final partition is limited by constant times the number of marked cells. This hints at the possibility to design a marking procedure that is limited only to cells of the partition whose subdivision will result in a conforming partition and therefore no completion step would be necessary. This talk will present such a strategy together with theoretical results about its near-optimal performance.

Thu, 23 May 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Operator preconditioning and some recent developments for boundary integral equations

Dr Carolina Urzua Torres
(Mathematical Institute (University of Oxford))
Abstract

In this talk, I am going to give an introduction to operator preconditioning as a general and robust strategy to precondition linear systems arising from Galerkin discretization of PDEs or Boundary Integral Equations. Then, in order to illustrate the applicability of this preconditioning technique, I will discuss the simple case of weakly singular and hypersingular integral equations, arising from exterior Dirichlet and Neumann BVPs for the Laplacian in 3D. Finally, I will show how we can also tackle operators with a more difficult structure, like the electric field integral equation (EFIE) on screens, which models the scattering of time-harmonic electromagnetic waves at perfectly conducting bounded infinitely thin objects, like patch antennas in 3D.

Thu, 16 May 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Parallel preconditioning for time-dependent PDEs and PDE control

Professor Andy Wathen
(Department of Mathematics)
Abstract

We present a novel approach to the solution of time-dependent PDEs via the so-called monolithic or all-at-once formulation.

This approach will be explained for simple parabolic problems and its utility in the context of PDE constrained optimization problems will be elucidated.

The underlying linear algebra includes circulant matrix approximations of Toeplitz-structured matrices and allows for effective parallel implementation. Simple computational results will be shown for the heat equation and the wave equation which indicate the potential as a parallel-in-time method.

This is joint work with Elle McDonald (CSIRO, Australia), Jennifer Pestana (Strathclyde University, UK) and Anthony Goddard (Durham University, UK)

Thu, 09 May 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Quasi-optimal and pressure robust discretizations of the Stokes equations.

Dr Pietro Zanotti
(TU Dortmund)
Abstract

ABSTRACT

We approximate the solution of the stationary Stokes equations with various conforming and nonconforming inf-sup stable pairs of finite element spaces on simplicial meshes. Based on each pair, we design a discretization that is quasi-optimal and pressure robust, in the sense that the velocity H^1-error is proportional to the best H^1-error to the analytical velocity. This shows that such a property can be achieved without using conforming and divergence-free pairs. We bound also the pressure L^2-error, only in terms of the best approximation errors to the analytical velocity and the analytical pressure. Our construction can be summarized as follows. First, a linear operator acts on discrete velocity test functions, before the application of the load functional, and maps the discrete kernel into the analytical one.

Second, in order to enforce consistency, we  possibly employ a new augmented Lagrangian formulation, inspired by Discontinuous Galerkin methods.

Thu, 07 Mar 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Flexible computational abstractions for complex preconditioners

Dr Lawrence Mitchell
(Durham University)
Abstract

Small block overlapping, and non-overlapping, Schwarz methods are theoretically highly attractive as multilevel smoothers for a wide variety of problems that are not amenable to point relaxation methods.  Examples include monolithic Vanka smoothers for Stokes, overlapping vertex-patch decompositions for $H(\text{div})$ and  $H(\text{curl})$ problems, along with nearly incompressible elasticity, and augmented Lagrangian schemes.

 While it is possible to manually program these different schemes,  their use in general purpose libraries has been held back by a lack   of generic, composable interfaces. We present a new approach to the   specification and development such additive Schwarz methods in PETSc  that cleanly separates the topological space decomposition from the  discretisation and assembly of the equations. Our preconditioner is  flexible enough to support overlapping and non-overlapping additive  Schwarz methods, and can be used to formulate line, and plane smoothers, Vanka iterations, amongst others. I will illustrate these new features with some examples utilising the Firedrake finite element library, in particular how the design of an approriate computational interface enables these schemes to be used as building blocks inside block preconditioners.

This is joint work with Patrick Farrell and Florian Wechsung (Oxford), and Matt Knepley (Buffalo).

Thu, 21 Feb 2019

14:00 - 15:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

Tomographic imaging with flat-field uncertainty

Prof Martin Skovgaard Andersen
(Danish Technical University)
Abstract

Classical methods for X-ray computed tomography (CT) are based on the assumption that the X-ray source intensity is known. In practice, however, the intensity is measured and hence uncertain. Under normal circumstances, when the exposure time is sufficiently high, this kind of uncertainty typically has a negligible effect on the reconstruction quality. However, in time- or dose-limited applications such as dynamic CT, this uncertainty may cause severe and systematic artifacts known as ring artifacts.
By modeling the measurement process and by taking uncertainties into account, it is possible to derive a convex reconstruction model that leads to improved reconstructions when the signal-to-noise ratio is low. We discuss some computational challenges associated with the model and illustrate its merits with some numerical examples based on simulated and real data.

Thu, 14 Feb 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Derivation, analysis and approximation of coupled PDEs on manifolds with high dimensionality gap

Prof Paolo Zunino
(Politecnico di Milano)
Abstract

 Multiscale methods based on coupled partial differential equations defined on bulk and embedded manifolds are still poorly explored from the theoretical standpoint, although they are successfully used in applications, such as microcirculation and flow in perforated subsurface reservoirs. This work aims at shedding light on some theoretical aspects of a multiscale method consisting of coupled partial differential equations defined on one-dimensional domains embedded into three-dimensional ones. Mathematical issues arise because the dimensionality gap between the bulk and the inclusions is larger than one, named as the high dimensionality gap case. First, we show that such model derives from a system of full three-dimensional equations, by the application of a topological model reduction approach. Secondly, we rigorously analyze the problem, showing that the averaging operators applied for the model reduction introduce a regularization effect that resolves the issues due to the singularity of solutions and to the ill-posedness of restriction operators. Then, we discretize the problem by means of the finite element method and we analyze the approximation error. Finally, we exploit the structure of the model reduction technique to analyze the modeling error. This study confirms that for infinitesimally small inclusions, the modeling error vanishes.

This is a joint work with Federica Laurino, Department of Mathematics, Politecnico di Milano.

Thu, 07 Feb 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Polynomial approximation of high-dimensional functions - from regular to irregular domains

Prof. Ben Adcock
(Simon Fraser University)
Abstract

Driven by its numerous applications in computational science, the approximation of smooth, high-dimensional functions via sparse polynomial expansions has received significant attention in the last five to ten years.  In the first part of this talk, I will give a brief survey of recent progress in this area.  In particular, I will demonstrate how the proper use of compressed sensing tools leads to new techniques for high-dimensional approximation which can mitigate the curse of dimensionality to a substantial extent.  The rest of the talk is devoted to approximating functions defined on irregular domains.  The vast majority of works on high-dimensional approximation assume the function in question is defined over a tensor-product domain.  Yet this assumption is often unrealistic.  I will introduce a method, known as polynomial frame approximation, suitable for broad classes of irregular domains and present theoretical guarantees for its approximation error, stability, and sample complexity.  These results show the suitability of this approach for high-dimensional approximation through the independence (or weak dependence) of the various guarantees on the ambient dimension d.  Time permitting, I will also discuss several extensions.

Thu, 31 Jan 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Inexact Ideas

Prof Trond Steihaug
(University of Bergen)
Abstract

When the linear system in Newton’s method is approximately solved using an iterative method we have an inexact or truncated Newton method. The outer method is Newton’s method and the inner iterations will be the iterative method. The Inexact Newton framework is now close to 30 years old and is widely used and given names like Newton-Arnoldi, Newton-CG depending on the inner iterative method. In this talk we will explore convergence properties when the outer iterative method is Gauss-Newton, the Halley method or an interior point method for linear programming problems.

Thu, 24 Jan 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Bespoke stochastic Galerkin approximation of nearly incompressible elasticity

Prof David Silvester
(Manchester University)
Abstract

We discuss the key role that bespoke linear algebra plays in modelling PDEs with random coefficients using stochastic Galerkin approximation methods. As a specific example, we consider nearly incompressible linear elasticity problems with an uncertain spatially varying Young's modulus. The uncertainty is modelled with a finite set of parameters with prescribed probability distribution.  We introduce a novel three-field mixed variational formulation of the PDE model and and  assess the stability with respect to a weighted norm. The main focus will be  the efficient solution of the associated high-dimensional indefinite linear system of equations. Eigenvalue bounds for the preconditioned system can be  established and shown to be independent of the discretisation parameters and the Poisson ratio.  We also  discuss an associated a posteriori error estimation strategy and assess proxies for the error reduction associated with selected enrichments of the approximation spaces.  We will show by example that these proxies enable the design of efficient  adaptive solution algorithms that terminate when the estimated error falls below a user-prescribed tolerance.

This is joint work with Arbaz Khan and Catherine Powell

Thu, 17 Jan 2019

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Second order directional shape derivatives on submanifolds

Dr Anton Schiela
(Bayreuth)
Abstract

Just like optimization needs derivatives, shape optimization needs shape derivatives. Their definition and computation is a classical subject, at least concerning first order shape derivatives. Second derivatives have been studied as well, but some aspects of their theory still remains a bit mysterious for practitioners. As a result, most algorithms for shape optimization are first order methods.

To understand this situation better and in a general way, we consider first and second order shape sensitivities of integrals on smooth submanifolds using a variant of shape differentiation. Instead of computing the second derivative as the derivative of the first derivative, we choose a one-parameter family of perturbations  and compute first and second derivatives with respect to that parameter. The result is a  quadratic form in terms of a perturbation vector field that yields a second order quadratic model of the perturbed functional, which can be used as the basis of a second order shape optimization algorithm. We discuss the structure of this derivative, derive domain expressions and Hadamard forms in a general geometric framework, and give a detailed geometric interpretation of the arising terms.

Finally, we use our results to construct a second order SQP-algorithm for shape optimization that exhibits indeed local fast convergence.

Thu, 29 Nov 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Alternative Mixed Integer Linear Programming Formulations for Globally Solving Standard Quadratic Programs

Prof. Alper Yidirim
(Koç University Istanbul)
Abstract

Standard quadratic programs have numerous applications and play an important role in copositivity detection. We consider reformulating a standard quadratic program as a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) problem. We propose alternative MILP reformulations that exploit the specific structure of standard quadratic programs. We report extensive computational results on various classes of instances. Our experiments reveal that our MILP reformulations significantly outperform other global solution approaches. 
This is joint work with Jacek Gondzio.

Thu, 22 Nov 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Some new finding for preconditioning of elliptic problems

Prof Kent-Andre Mardal
(University of Oslo)
Abstract


In this talk I will present two recent findings concerning the preconditioning of elliptic problems. The first result concerns preconditioning of elliptic problems with variable coefficient K by an inverse Laplacian. Here we show that there is a close relationship between the eigenvalues of the preconditioned system and K. 
The second results concern the problem on mixed form where K approaches zero. Here, we show a uniform inf-sup condition and corresponding robust preconditioning. 

Thu, 15 Nov 2018

14:00 - 15:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

Block Low-Rank Matrices: Main Results and Recent Advances

Mr Théo Mary
(Manchester University)
Abstract

In many applications requiring the solution of a linear system Ax=b, the matrix A has been shown to have a low-rank property: its off-diagonal blocks have low numerical rank, i.e., they can be well approximated by matrices of small rank. Several matrix formats have been proposed to exploit this property depending on how the block partitioning of the matrix is computed.
In this talk, I will discuss the block low-rank (BLR) format, which partitions the matrix with a simple, flat 2D blocking. I will present the main characteristics of BLR matrices, in particular in terms of asymptotic complexity and parallel performance. I will then discuss some recent advances and ongoing research on BLR matrices: their multilevel extension, their use as preconditioners for iterative solvers, the error analysis of their factorization, and finally the use of fast matrix arithmetic to accelerate BLR matrix operations.

Thu, 08 Nov 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Oscillation in a posteriori error analysis

Prof. Christian Kreuzer
(University of Dortmund)
Abstract


A posteriori error estimators are a key tool for the quality assessment of given finite element approximations to an unknown PDE solution as well as for the application of adaptive techniques. Typically, the estimators are equivalent to the error up to an additive term, the so called oscillation. It is a common believe that this is the price for the `computability' of the estimator and that the oscillation is of higher order than the error. Cohen, DeVore, and Nochetto [CoDeNo:2012], however, presented an example, where the error vanishes with the generic optimal rate, but the oscillation does not. Interestingly, in this example, the local $H^{-1}$-norms are assumed to be computed exactly and thus the computability of the estimator cannot be the reason for the asymptotic overestimation. In particular, this proves both believes wrong in general. In this talk, we present a new approach to posteriori error analysis, where the oscillation is dominated by the error. The crucial step is a new splitting of the data into oscillation and oscillation free data. Moreover, the estimator is computable if the discrete linear system can essentially be assembled exactly.
 

Thu, 01 Nov 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Higher order partial differential equation constrained derivative information using automated code generation

Dr James Maddison
(Edinburgh University)
Abstract

The FEniCS system [1] allows the description of finite element discretisations of partial differential equations using a high-level syntax, and the automated conversion of these representations to working code via automated code generation. In previous work described in [2] the high-level representation is processed automatically to derive discrete tangent-linear and adjoint models. The processing of the model code at a high level eases the technical difficulty associated with management of data in adjoint calculations, allowing the use of optimal data management strategies [3].

This previous methodology is extended to enable the calculation of higher order partial differential equation constrained derivative information. The key additional step is to treat tangent-linear
equations on an equal footing with originating forward equations, and in particular to treat these in a manner which can themselves be further processed to enable the derivation of associated adjoint information, and the derivation of higher order tangent-linear equations, to arbitrary order. This enables the calculation of higher order derivative information -- specifically the contraction of a Kth order derivative against (K - 1) directions -- while still making use of optimal data management strategies. Specific applications making use of Hessian information associated with models written using the FEniCS system are presented.

[1] "Automated solution of differential equations by the finite element method: The FEniCS book", A. Logg, K.-A. Mardal, and  G. N. Wells (editors), Springer, 2012
[2] P. E. Farrell, D. A. Ham, S. W. Funke, and M. E. Rognes, "Automated derivation of the adjoint of high-level transient finite element programs", SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing 35(4), C369--C393, 2013
[3] A. Griewank, and A. Walther, "Algorithm 799: Revolve: An implementation of checkpointing for the reverse or adjoint mode of computational differentiation", ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software 26(1), 19--45, 2000

Thu, 25 Oct 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Augmented Arnoldi-Tikhonov Methods for Ill-posed Problems

Prof Kirk Soodhalter
(Trinity College Dublin)
Abstract

$$
\def\curl#1{\left\{#1\right\}}
\def\vek#1{\mathbf{#1}}
$$
lll-posed problems arise often in the context of scientific applications in which one cannot directly observe the object or quantity of interest. However, indirect observations or measurements can be made, and the observable data $y$ can be represented as the wanted observation $x$ being acted upon by an operator $\mathcal{A}$. Thus we want to solve the operator equation \begin{equation}\label{eqn.Txy} \mathcal{A} x = y, \end{equation} (1) often formulated in some Hilbert space $H$ with $\mathcal{A}:H\rightarrow H$ and $x,y\in H$. The difficulty then is that these problems are generally ill-posed, and thus $x$ does not depend continuously on the on the right-hand side. As $y$ is often derived from measurements, one has instead a perturbed $y^{\delta}$ such that ${y - y^{\delta}}_{H}<\delta$. Thus due to the ill-posedness, solving (1) with $y^{\delta}$ is not guaranteed to produce a meaningful solution. One such class of techniques to treat such problems are the Tikhonov-regularization methods. One seeks in reconstructing the solution to balance fidelity to the data against size of some functional evaluation of the reconstructed image (e.g., the norm of the reconstruction) to mitigate the effects of the ill-posedness. For some $\lambda>0$, we solve \begin{equation}\label{eqn.tikh} x_{\lambda} = \textrm{argmin}_{\widetilde{x}\in H}\left\lbrace{\left\|{b - A\widetilde{x}} \right\|_{H}^{2} + \lambda \left\|{\widetilde{x}}\right\|_{H}^{2}} \right\rbrace. \end{equation} In this talk, we discuss some new strategies for treating discretized versions of this problem. Here, we consider a discreditized, finite dimensional version of (1), \begin{equation}\label{eqn.Axb} Ax =  b \mbox{ with }  A\in \mathbb{R}^{n\times n}\mbox{ and } b\in\mathbb{R}^{n}, \end{equation} which inherits a discrete version of ill conditioning from [1]. We propose methods built on top of the Arnoldi-Tikhonov method of Lewis and Reichel, whereby one builds the Krylov subspace \begin{equation}
\mathcal{K}_{j}(\vek A,\vek w) = {\rm span\,}\curl{\vek w,\vek A\vek w,\vek A^{2}\vek w,\ldots,\vek A^{j-1}\vek w}\mbox{ where } \vek w\in\curl{\vek b,\vek A\vek b}
\end{equation}
and solves the discretized Tikhonov minimization problem projected onto that subspace. We propose to extend this strategy to setting of augmented Krylov subspace methods. Thus, we project onto a sum of subspaces of the form $\mathcal{U} + \mathcal{K}_{j}$ where $\mathcal{U}$ is a fixed subspace and $\mathcal{K}_{j}$ is a Krylov subspace. It turns out there are multiple ways to do this leading to different algorithms. We will explain how these different methods arise mathematically and demonstrate their effectiveness on a few example problems. Along the way, some new mathematical properties of the Arnoldi-Tikhonov method are also proven.

Thu, 18 Oct 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Finite Size Effects — Random Matrices, Quantum Chaos, and Riemann Zeros

Prof Folkmar Bornemann
(TU Munich)
Abstract

Since the legendary 1972 encounter of H. Montgomery and F. Dyson at tea time in Princeton, a statistical correspondence of the non-trivial zeros of the Riemann Zeta function with eigenvalues of high-dimensional random matrices has emerged. Surrounded by many deep conjectures, there is a striking analogyto the energy levels of a quantum billiard system with chaotic dynamics. Thanks 
to extensive calculation of Riemann zeros by A. Odlyzko, overwhelming numerical evidence has been found for the quantum analogy. The statistical accuracy provided by an enormous dataset of more than one billion zeros reveals distinctive finite size effects. Using the physical analogy, a precise prediction of these effects was recently accomplished through the numerical evaluation of operator determinants and their perturbation series (joint work with P. Forrester and A. Mays, Melbourne).
 

Thu, 11 Oct 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Least-Squares Padé approximation of Helmholtz problems with parametric/stochastic wavenumber

Prof Fabio Nobile
(EPFL Lausanne)
Abstract

The present work concerns the approximation of the solution map associated to the parametric Helmholtz boundary value problem, i.e., the map which associates to each (real) wavenumber belonging to a given interval of interest the corresponding solution of the Helmholtz equation. We introduce a single-point Least Squares (LS) rational Padé-type approximation technique applicable to any meromorphic Hilbert space-valued univariate map, and we prove the uniform convergence of the Padé approximation error on any compact subset of the interval of interest that excludes any pole. We also present a simplified and more efficient version, named Fast LS-Padé, applicable to Helmholtz-type parametric equations with normal operators.

The LS-Padé techniques are then employed to approximate the frequency response map associated to various parametric time-harmonic wave problems, namely, a transmission/reflection problem, a scattering problem and a problem in high-frequency regime. In all cases we establish the meromorphy of the frequency response map. The Helmholtz equation with stochastic wavenumber is also considered. In particular, for Lipschitz functionals of the solution, and their corresponding probability measures, we establish weak convergence of the measure derived from the LS-Padé approximant to the true one. Two-dimensioanl numerical tests are performed, which confirm the effectiveness of the approximation method.As of the dates

 Joint work with: Francesca Bonizzoni and  Ilaria Perugia (Uni. Vienna), Davide Pradovera (EPFL)

Thu, 14 Jun 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Applied Random Matrix Theory

Prof. Joel Tropp
(Caltech)
Abstract

Random matrices now play a role in many areas of theoretical, applied, and computational mathematics. Therefore, it is desirable to have tools for studying random matrices that are flexible, easy to use, and powerful. Over the last fifteen years, researchers have developed a remarkable family of results, called matrix concentration inequalities, that balance these criteria. This talk offers an invitation to the field of matrix concentration inequalities and their applications.

Thu, 07 Jun 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Multilevel and multifidelity approaches to UQ for PDEs

Prof. Max Gunzburger
(Florida State University)
Abstract

We first consider multilevel Monte Carlo and stochastic collocation methods for determining statistical information about an output of interest that depends on the solution of a PDE with inputs that depend on random parameters. In our context, these methods connect a hierarchy of spatial grids to the amount of sampling done for a given grid, resulting in dramatic acceleration in the convergence of approximations. We then consider multifidelity methods for the same purpose which feature a variety of models that have different fidelities. For example, we could have coarser grid discretizations, reduced-order models, simplified physics, surrogates such as interpolants, and, in principle, even experimental data. No assumptions are made about the fidelity of the models relative to the “truth” model of interest so that unlike multilevel methods, there is no a priori model hierarchy available. However, our approach can still greatly accelerate the convergence of approximations.

Thu, 24 May 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Optimization, equilibria, energy and risk

Prof. Michael Ferris
(University of Wisconsin)
Abstract


In the past few decades, power grids across the world have become dependent on markets that aim to efficiently match supply with demand at all times via a variety of pricing and auction mechanisms. These markets are based on models that capture interactions between producers, transmission and consumers. Energy producers typically maximize profits by optimally allocating and scheduling resources over time. A dynamic equilibrium aims to determine prices and dispatches that can be transmitted over the electricity grid to satisfy evolving consumer requirements for energy at different locations and times. Computation allows large scale practical implementations of socially optimal models to be solved as part of the market operation, and regulations can be imposed that aim to ensure competitive behaviour of market participants.

Questions remain that will be outlined in this presentation.

Firstly, the recent explosion in the use of renewable supply such as wind, solar and hydro has led to increased volatility in this system. We demonstrate how risk can impose significant costs on the system that are not modeled in the context of socially optimal power system markets and highlight the use of contracts to reduce or recover these costs. We also outline how battery storage can be used as an effective hedging instrument.

Secondly, how do we guarantee continued operation in rarely occuring situations and when failures occur and how do we price this robustness?

Thirdly, how do we guarantee appropriate participant behaviour? Specifically, is it possible for participants to develop strategies that move the system to operating points that are not socially optimal?

Fourthly, how do we ensure enough transmission (and generator) capacity in the long term, and how do we recover the costs of this enhanced infrastructure?
 

Thu, 17 May 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Isogeometric multiresolution shape and topology optimisation

Dr. Fehmi Cirak
(Cambridge)
Abstract

Advances in manufacturing technologies, most prominently in additive manufacturing or 3d printing, are making it possible to fabricate highly optimised products with increasing geometric and hierarchical complexity. This talk will introduce our ongoing work on design optimisation that combines CAD-compatible geometry representations, multiresolution geometry processing techniques and immersed finite elements with classical shape and topology calculus. As example applications,the shape optimisation of mechanical structures and electromechanical components, and the topology optimisation of lattice-skin structures will be discussed.

Thu, 10 May 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

New Directions in Reduced Order Modeling

Prof. Jan Hesthaven
(EPFL (Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne))
Abstract

The development of reduced order models for complex applications, offering the promise for rapid and accurate evaluation of the output of complex models under parameterized variation, remains a very active research area. Applications are found in problems which require many evaluations, sampled over a potentially large parameter space, such as in optimization, control, uncertainty quantification and applications where near real-time response is needed.

However, many challenges remain to secure the flexibility, robustness, and efficiency needed for general large-scale applications, in particular for nonlinear and/or time-dependent problems.

After giving a brief general introduction to reduced order models, we discuss developments in two different directions. In the first part, we discuss recent developments of reduced methods that conserve chosen invariants for nonlinear time-dependent problems. We pay particular attention to the development of reduced models for Hamiltonian problems and propose a greedy approach to build the basis. As we shall demonstrate, attention to the construction of the basis must be paid not only to ensure accuracy but also to ensure stability of the reduced model. Time permitting, we shall also briefly discuss how to extend the approach to include more general dissipative problems through the notion of port-Hamiltonians, resulting in reduced models that remain stable even in the limit of vanishing viscosity and also touch on extensions to Euler and Navier-Stokes equations.

The second part of the talk discusses the combination of reduced order modeling for nonlinear problems with the use of neural networks to overcome known problems of on-line efficiency for general nonlinear problems. We discuss the general idea in which training of the neural network becomes part of the offline part and demonstrate its potential through a number of examples, including for the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations with geometric variations.

This work has been done with in collaboration with B.F. Afkram (EPFL, CH), N. Ripamonti EPFL, CH) and S. Ubbiali (USI, CH).

Thu, 03 May 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Robust numerical methods for nonlocal diffusion and convection-diffusion equations.

Prof. Espen Jakobsen
(Trondheim)
Abstract


In this talk we will introduce and analyse a class of robust numerical methods for nonlocal possibly nonlinear diffusion and convection-diffusion equations. Diffusion and convection-diffusion models are popular in Physics, Chemistry, Engineering, and Economics, and in many models the diffusion is anomalous or nonlocal. This means that the underlying “particle" distributions are not Gaussian, but rather follow more general Levy distributions, distributions that need not have second moments and can satisfy (generalised) central limit theorems. We will focus on models with nonlinear possibly degenerate diffusions like fractional Porous Medium Equations, Fast Diffusion Equations, and Stefan (phase transition) Problems, with or without convection. The solutions of these problems can be very irregular and even possess shock discontinuities. The combination of nonlinear problems and irregular solutions makes these problems challenging to solve numerically.
The methods we will discuss are monotone finite difference quadrature methods that are robust in the sense that they “always” converge. By that we mean that under very weak assumptions, they converge to the correct generalised possibly discontinuous generalised solution. In some cases we can also obtain error estimates. The plan of the talk is: 1. to give a short introduction to the models, 2. explain the numerical methods, 3. give results and elements of the analysis for pure diffusion equations, and 4. give results and ideas of the analysis for convection-diffusion equations. 
 

Thu, 26 Apr 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Computing a Quantity of Interest from Data Observations

Prof. Ron DeVore
(Texas A & M)
Abstract


A very common problem in Science is that we have some Data Observations and we are interested in either approximating the function underlying the data or computing some quantity of interest about this function.  This talk will discuss what are best algorithms for such tasks and how we can evaluate the performance of any such algorithm.
 

Thu, 08 Mar 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Nonlinear edge diffusion and the discrete maximum principle

Gabriel Barrenechea
(University of Strathclyde)
Abstract

In this talk I will review recent results on the analysis of shock-capturing-type methods applied to convection-dominated problems. The method of choice is a variant of the Algebraic Flux-Correction (AFC) scheme. This scheme has received some attention over the last two decades due to its very satisfactory numerical performance. Despite this attention, until very recently there was no stability and convergence analysis for it. Thus, the purpose of the works reviewed in this talk was to bridge that gap. The first step towards the full analysis of the method is a rewriting of it as a nonlinear edge-based diffusion method. This writing makes it possible to present a unified analysis of the different variants of it. So, minimal assumptions on the components of the method are stated in such a way that the resulting scheme satisfies the Discrete Maximum Principle (DMP) and is convergence. One property that will be discussed in detail is the linearity preservation. This property has been linked to the good performance of methods of this kind. We will discuss in detail its role and the impact of it in the overall convergence of the method. Time permitting, some results on a posteriori error estimation will also be presented. 
This talk will gather contributions with A. Allendes (UTFSM, Chile), E. Burman (UCL, UK), V. John (WIAS, Berlin), F. Karakatsani (Chester, UK), P. Knobloch (Prague, Czech Republic), and 
R. Rankin (U. of Nottingham, China).

Thu, 01 Mar 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

New Directions in Reduced Order Modeling

Prof Jan Hesthaven
(EPFL Lausanne)
Abstract

The development of reduced order models for complex applications, offering the promise for rapid and accurate evaluation of the output of complex models under parameterized variation, remains a very active research area. Applications are found in problems which require many evaluations, sampled over a potentially large parameter space, such as in optimization, control, uncertainty quantification and applications where near real-time response is needed.

However, many challenges remain to secure the flexibility, robustness, and efficiency needed for general large-scale applications, in particular for nonlinear and/or time-dependent problems.

After giving a brief general introduction to reduced order models, we discuss developments in two different directions. In the first part, we discuss recent developments of reduced methods that conserve chosen invariants for nonlinear time-dependent problems. We pay particular attention to the development of reduced models for Hamiltonian problems and propose a greedy approach to build the basis. As we shall demonstrate, attention to the construction of the basis must be paid not only to ensure accuracy but also to ensure stability of the reduced model. Time permitting, we shall also briefly discuss how to extend the approach to include more general dissipative problems through the notion of port-Hamiltonians, resulting in reduced models that remain stable even in the limit of vanishing viscosity and also touch on extensions to Euler and Navier-Stokes equations.

The second part of the talk discusses the combination of reduced order modeling for nonlinear problems with the use of neural networks to overcome known problems of on-line efficiency for general nonlinear problems. We discuss the general idea in which training of the neural network becomes part of the offline part and demonstrate its potential through a number of examples, including for the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations with geometric variations.

This work has been done with in collaboration with B.F. Afkram (EPFL, CH), N. Ripamonti EPFL, CH) and S. Ubbiali (USI, CH).

Thu, 22 Feb 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Parallel-in-time integration for time-dependent partial differential equations

Daniel Ruprecht
(Leeds University)
Abstract

The rapidly increasing number of cores in high-performance computing systems causes a multitude of challenges for developers of numerical methods. New parallel algorithms are required to unlock future growth in computing power for applications and energy efficiency and algorithm-based fault tolerance are becoming increasingly important. So far, most approaches to parallelise the numerical solution of partial differential equations focussed on spatial solvers, leaving time as a bottleneck. Recently, however, time stepping methods that offer some degree of concurrency, so-called parallel-in-time integration methods, have started to receive more attention.

I will introduce two different numerical algorithms, Parareal (by Lions et al., 2001) and PFASST (by Emmett and Minion, 2012), that allow to exploit concurrency along the time dimension in parallel computer simulations solving partial differential equations. Performance results for both methods on different architectures and for different equations will be presented. The PFASST algorithm is based on merging ideas from Parareal, spectral deferred corrections (SDC, an iterative approach to derive high-order time stepping methods by Dutt et al. 2000) and nonlinear multi-grid. Performance results for PFASST on close to half a million cores will illustrate the potential of the approach. Algorithmic modifications like IPFASST will be introduced that can further reduce solution times. Also, recent results showing how parallel-in-time integration can provide algorithm-based tolerance against hardware faults will be shown.

Thu, 15 Feb 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Highly accurate integral equation based methods for surfactant laden drops in two and three dimensions

Anna-Karin Tornberg
(KTH Stockholm)
Abstract

In micro-fluidics, at small scales where inertial effects become negligible, surface to volume ratios are large and the interfacial processes are extremely important for the overall dynamics. Integral
equation based methods are attractive for the simulations of e.g. droplet-based microfluidics, with tiny water drops dispersed in oil, stabilized by surfactants. In boundary integral formulations for
Stokes flow, jumps in pressure and velocity gradients are naturally taken care of, viscosity ratios enter only in coefficients of the equations, and only the drop surfaces must be discretized and not the volume inside nor in between.

We present numerical methods for drops with insoluble surfactants, both in two and three dimensions. We discretize the integral equations using Nyström methods, and special care is taken in the evaluation of singular and also nearly singular integrals that is needed in the case of close drop interactions. A spectral method is used to solve the advection-diffusion equation on each drop surface that describes the evolution of surfactant concentration. The drop velocity and surfactant concentration couple together through an equation of state for the surface tension coefficient. An adaptive time-stepping strategy is developed for the coupled problem, with the constraint to minimize the number of Stokes solves, since this is the computationally most expensive part.

For high quality discretization of the drops throughout the simulations, a hybrid method is used in two dimensions, offering an arc-length parameterization of the interface. In three dimensions, a
reparameterization procedure is developed to optimize the spherical harmonics representation of the drop, while conserving the drop volume and amount of surfactant.

We present results from some validation tests and illustrate the ability of the numerical methods in different challenging problems.

Thu, 01 Feb 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Optimisation for Gradient Boosted Trees with Risk Control

Ruth Misener
(Imperial College)
Abstract


Decision trees usefully represent the sparse, high dimensional and noisy nature of chemical data from experiments. Having learned a function from this data, we may want to thereafter optimise the function, e.g. for picking the best catalyst for a chemical process. This work studies a mixed-integer non-linear optimisation problem involving: (i) gradient boosted trees modelling catalyst behaviour, (ii) penalty functions mitigating risk, and (iii) penalties enforcing chemical composition constraints. We develop several heuristic methods to find feasible solutions, and an exact, branch and bound algorithm that leverages structural properties of the gradient boost trees and penalty functions. We computationally test our methods on an industrial instance from BASF.
This work was completed in collaboration with Mr Miten Mistry and Dr Dimitris Letsios at Imperial College London and Dr Robert Lee and Dr Gerhard Krennrich from BASF.
 

Thu, 25 Jan 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Numerical integrators for rank-constrained differential equations

Bart Vandereycken
(University of Geneva)
Abstract

We present discrete methods for computing low-rank approximations of time-dependent tensors that are the solution of a differential equation. The approximation format can be Tucker, tensor trains, MPS or hierarchical tensors. We will consider two types of discrete integrators: projection methods based on quasi-optimal metric projection, and splitting methods based on inexact solutions of substeps. For both approaches we show numerically and theoretically that their behaviour is superior compared to standard methods applied to the so-called gauged equations. In particular, the error bounds are robust in the presence of small singular values of the tensor’s matricisations. Based on joint work with Emil Kieri, Christian Lubich, and Hanna Walach.

Thu, 18 Jan 2018

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Hybrid discontinuous Galerkin discretisation and domain decomposition preconditioners for the Stokes problem

Victorita Dolean
(University of Strathclyde)
Abstract

Solving the Stokes equation by an optimal domain decomposition method derived algebraically involves the use of non standard interface conditions whose discretisation is not trivial. For this reason the use of approximation methods such as hybrid discontinuous Galerkin appears as an appropriate strategy: on the one hand they provide the best compromise in terms of the number of degrees of freedom in between standard continuous and discontinuous Galerkin methods, and on the other hand the degrees of freedom used in the non standard interface conditions are naturally defined at the boundary between elements. In this work we introduce the coupling between a well chosen discretisation method (hybrid discontinuous Galerkin) and a novel and efficient domain decomposition method to solve the Stokes system. We present the detailed analysis of the hybrid discontinuous Galerkin method for the Stokes problem with non standard boundary conditions. This analysis is supported by numerical evidence. In addition, the advantage of the new preconditioners over more classical choices is also supported by numerical experiments.

This work was done in collaboration with G. Barrenechea, M. Bosy (Univ. Strathclyde) and F. Nataf, P-H Tournier (Univ of Paris VI)

Thu, 07 Dec 2017
14:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

Truncated SVD Approximation via Kronecker Summations

Professor James Nagy
(Emory University)
Abstract


In this talk we describe an approach to approximate the truncated singular value decomposition of a large matrix by first decomposing the matrix into a sum of Kronecker products. Our approach can be used to more efficiently approximate a large number of singular values and vectors than other well known schemes, such as iterative algorithms based on the Golub-Kahan bidiagonalization or randomized matrix algorithms. We provide theoretical results and numerical experiments to demonstrate accuracy of our approximation, and show how the approximation can be used to solve large scale ill-posed inverse problems, either as an approximate filtering method, or as a preconditioner to accelerate iterative algorithms.
 

Thu, 30 Nov 2017

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Error analysis for a diffuse interface approach to an advection-diffusion equation on a moving surface

Dr Vanessa Styles
(University of Sussex)
Abstract

We analyze a fully discrete numerical scheme for solving a parabolic PDE on a moving surface. The method is based on a diffuse interface approach that involves a level set description of the moving surface. Under suitable conditions on the spatial grid size, the time step and the interface width we obtain stability and error bounds with respect to natural norms. Test calculations are presented that confirm our analysis.

Thu, 23 Nov 2017

14:00 - 15:00
L4

(Discrete) spline interpolation on Riemannian manifolds

Professor Benedikt Wirth
(University of Münster)
Abstract

Spline curves represent a simple and efficient tool for data interpolation in Euclidean space. During the past decades, however, more and more applications have emerged that require interpolation in (often high-dimensional) nonlinear spaces such as Riemannian manifolds. An example is the generation of motion sequences in computer graphics, where the animated figure represents a curve in a Riemannian space of shapes. Two particularly useful spline interpolation methods derive from a variational principle: linear splines minimize the average squared velocity and cubic splines minimize the average squared acceleration among all interpolating curves. Those variational principles and their discrete analogues can be used to define continuous and discretized spline curves on (possibly infinite-dimensional) Riemannian manifolds. However, it turns out that well-posedness of cubic splines is much more intricate on nonlinear and high-dimensional spaces and requires quite strong conditions on the underlying manifold. We will analyse and discuss linear and cubic splines as well as their discrete counterparts on Riemannian manifolds and show a few applications.

Thu, 16 Nov 2017

14:00 - 15:00
L4

New Formulations for Generator Maintenance Scheduling in Hydropower Systems

Professor Miguel Anjos
(École Polytechnique Montréal)
Abstract

Maintenance activities help prevent costly power generator breakdowns but because generators under maintenance are typically unavailable, the impact of maintenance schedules is significant and their cost must be accounted for when planning maintenance. In this paper we address the generator maintenance scheduling problem in hydropower systems. While this problem has been widely studied, specific operating conditions of hydroelectric systems have received less attention. We present a mixed-integer linear programming model that considers the time windows of the maintenance activities, as well as the nonlinearities and disjunctions of the hydroelectric production functions. Because the resulting model is hard to solve, we also propose an extended formulation, a set reduction approach that uses logical conditions for excluding unnecessary set elements from the model, and valid inequalities. Computational experiments using a variety of instances adapted from a real hydropower system in Canada support the conclusion that the extended formulation with set reduction achieves the best results in terms of computational time and optimality gap. This is joint work with Jesus Rodriguez, Pascal Cote and Guy Desaulniers.

Thu, 02 Nov 2017

14:00 - 15:00
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, nr Didcot

Point-spread function reconstruction in ground-based astronomy

Professor Raymond Chan
(Chinese University of Hong Kong)
Abstract

Because of atmospheric turbulence, images of objects in outer space acquired via ground-based telescopes are usually blurry.  One way to estimate the blurring kernel or point spread function (PSF) is to make use of the aberration of wavefront received at the telescope, i.e., the phase. However only the low-resolution wavefront gradients can be collected by wavefront sensors. In this talk, I will discuss how to use regularization methods to reconstruct high-resolution phase gradients and then use them to recover the phase and the PSF in high accuracy. I will end by relating the problem to high-resolution image reconstruction and methods for solving it.
Joint work with Rui Zhao and research supported by HKRGC.

Thu, 26 Oct 2017

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Solving discrete conic optimization problems using disjunctive programming

Dr Pietro Belotti
Abstract

Several optimization problems combine nonlinear constraints with the integrality of a subset of variables. For an important class of problems  called Mixed Integer Second-Order Cone Optimization (MISOCO), with applications in facility location, robust optimization, and finance, among others, these nonlinear constraints are second-order (or Lorentz) cones.

For such problems, as for many discrete optimization problems, it is crucial to understand the properties of the union of two disjoint sets of feasible solutions. To this end, we apply the disjunctive programming paradigm to MISOCO and present conditions under which the convex hull of two disjoint sets can be obtained by intersecting the feasible set with a specially constructed second-order cone. Computational results show that such cone has a positive impact on the solution of MISOCO problems.

Thu, 19 Oct 2017

14:00 - 15:00
L4

Scattering by fractal screens - functional analysis and computation

Dr David Hewett
(University College London)
Abstract


The mathematical analysis and numerical simulation of acoustic and electromagnetic wave scattering by planar screens is a classical topic. The standard technique involves reformulating the problem as a boundary integral equation on the screen, which can be solved numerically using a boundary element method. Theory and computation are both well-developed for the case where the screen is an open subset of the plane with smooth (e.g. Lipschitz or smoother) boundary. In this talk I will explore the case where the screen is an arbitrary subset of the plane; in particular, the screen could have fractal boundary, or itself be a fractal. Such problems are of interest in the study of fractal antennas in electrical engineering, light scattering by snowflakes/ice crystals in atmospheric physics, and in certain diffraction problems in laser optics. The roughness of the screen presents challenging questions concerning how boundary conditions should be enforced, and the appropriate function space setting. But progress is possible and there is interesting behaviour to be discovered: for example, a sound-soft screen with zero area (planar measure zero) can scatter waves provided the fractal dimension of the set is large enough. Accurate computations are also challenging because of the need to adapt the mesh to the fine structure of the fractal. As well as presenting numerical results, I will outline some of the outstanding open questions from the point of view of numerical analysis. This is joint work with Simon Chandler-Wilde (Reading) and Andrea Moiola (Pavia).